1. Home
  2. Renters Insurance

Find the Best Renters Insurance in Green Bay, WI

If you’re renting your home and there’s a fire, theft or other mishap, only the structure is the property owner’s responsibility. Their insurance will likely not cover your personal belongings. For that, you need renters insurance. We researched the best renters insurance in Green Bay, so you know what to look for when choosing a policy provider.

Take a Home Security Systems Quiz

Get matched with an Authorized Partner

Compare Top Renters Insurance

Overall satisfaction rating
  • Up to $250,000 of personal property and $1 million of liability
  • Discount for bundling renters insurance and pet insurance
  • Cancel your policy at any time
  • Available in Green Bay and select states
Learn More Read More
  • Best rates all in one place
  • Helped over 4.5 million customers
  • Seamless, secure online payments
  • Available in Green Bay

Wide choice of A-rated insurers!

Serves residents in
Green Bay, WI
(855) 695-2255
Read More
  • Insurers for your needs & budget
  • Largest online marketplace
  • Fast, free quote comparison
  • Available in Green Bay
Serves residents in
Green Bay, WI
(855) 522-3444
Read More
Pagel & Associates Insurance Agency
  • M-Th: 8am - 5pm
  • F: 8am - 3pm
  • Sat and Sun: By appointment only
  • pagelasc.com/renters-insurance
1497 6th St., Ste. E
Green Bay, WI 54304
(702) 876-4006
State Farm Insurance: Tiona Petrouske
  • M-F: 9am - 5pm
  • Closed Sat and Sun
  • mygreenbayagent.com
1263 Main St., Ste. 125
Green Bay, WI 54302
(920) 437-9000
American Family Insurance: Joseph Havel
  • M-Th: 8am - 5pm
  • F: 8:30am - 5:30pm
  • Sat and Sun: By appointment only
  • agent.amfam.com/joseph-havel
849 Cormier Rd.
Green Bay, WI 54304
(920) 965-0600
Green Bay Insurance Center
  • M-F: 8am - 5pm
  • Closed Sat and Sun
  • gbic.com/services/personal-insurance
417 S. Monroe Ave.
Green Bay, WI 54301
(920) 437-9281
Allstate Insurance: Michael Bierke
  • M-Th: 9am - 6pm
  • F: 9am - 5pm
  • Closed Sat and Sun
  • agents.allstate.com/michael-bierke-green-bay-wi.html
2555 Continental Ct., Ste. 3
Green Bay, WI 54311
(920) 468-3300
Farmers Insurance: Karen Van Liere-Matuszak
  • M-F: 8:30am - 5:30pm
  • Sat: By appointment only
  • Closed Sun
  • agents.farmers.com/wi/green-bay/karen-van-liere-matuszak
2685 W. Mason St., Ste. C
Green Bay, WI 54303
(920) 297-2007
Peter Baierl Insurance & Investments
  • M-F: 8:30am - 5pm
  • Closed Sat and Sun
  • baierlinsurance.com/personal-insurance/renters-insurance
1345 W. Mason St.
Green Bay, WI 54303
(920) 490-1022
Northeast Insurance Center
  • M-Th: 8:30am - 5pm
  • F: 8:30am - 4pm
  • Closed Sat and Sun
  • northeastinsurance.biz/products/home-insurance/renters-insurance
1345A North Rd., Ste. 100
Green Bay, WI 54313
(920) 592-0500

How to choose rental insurance in Green Bay


Green Bay residents pay nearly $750 on rent each month, but paying a small amount more in renters insurance could save policyholders thousands of dollars in an emergency.

Renters insurance covers your personal property should it be stolen or damaged in a covered event. It can also cover your belongings if they get stolen outside of your home.

Some policies cover the cash value of damaged items, while others cover the replacement cost. Policies that pay the cash value factor in depreciation, which means you only receive enough money to re-purchase the same items secondhand. Alternatively, policies that offer the replacement cost will pay for a new comparable item. Replacement cost is often a higher payout, but those plans cost more monthly.

Renters insurance also guards against financial liability should someone accidentally get hurt in your home or you unintentionally damage someone else’s property.

If an emergency forces you to leave your home, some renters insurance policies will pay your hotel bills and other charges you incur as a result.

It’s important to note what renters insurance doesn’t cover:

  • It usually covers water damage, but not flood damage.
  • It doesn’t cover earthquake damage, though that is a minimal threat in Green Bay.
  • Your car doesn’t qualify as your property for this purpose and still requires auto insurance.
  • You and your family’s injuries fall under medical insurance, even if they occur in the home.

How much does renters insurance cost in Green Bay?

Renters insurance in Green Bay costs an average of $15 to $30 a month, though it depends on several factors, including your:

  • Total coverage amount
  • Deductible
  • Type of property coverage (cash value or replacement)
  • Location

Parents’ insurance may cover their children in college, so UW-Green Bay students should check before purchasing renters insurance.

Once you have renters insurance, it’s important to keep an up-to-date inventory of your belongings and to revisit your current policy periodically to ensure your coverage is adequate. As you buy new things, your coverage needs may change. Unusually valuable items, such as art, jewelry or collectibles, may require an additional rider to get full coverage.

Renters Insurance Reviews


Lemonade offers renters insurance, homeowners insurance and pet health insurance in Wisconsin and select states. Renters policies cover personal property, liability and temporary living expenses. Add Lemonade’s Extra Coverage for valuables like jewelry and fine art, which includes a $0 deductible and covers accidental loss. Use Lemonade’s app to apply for a policy and file claims in just minutes. The company handles and pays 30% of claims instantly. Lemonade takes a flat fee of premiums and donates leftover funds to charities chosen by its customers.

Lemonade Learn More


Policygenius has helped over 4.5 million people find the right insurance. After answering some questions online to determine how much coverage you need, this service secures quotes from multiple policy providers and explains your options. Reviewers appreciate Policygenius’s responsiveness and how easy it makes the process.



EverQuote is a marketplace for all kinds of insurance. Users fill out a short form to describe their needs, and policy providers reach out with quotes, often within minutes. However, some reviewers did not like being contacted by third parties and needing to fill out some information more than once.