1. Home
  2. Car Insurance

Find the Best Car Insurance Companies in Green Bay, WI

Auto insurance is a form of financial protection that covers you in the event of a car accident and other vehicle-related mishaps. At a minimum, Wisconsin drivers and vehicle owners must have liability coverage, but many consumers purchase collision and comprehensive policies. The multiple ways to purchase, the different combinations of coverage and the complex terminology can be overwhelming. We researched the best car insurance companies in Green Bay to simplify your decision.

Take an Extended Auto Warranty Quiz

Get matched with an Authorized Partner

Compare Top Car Insurance

  • Quotes from local agents and top car insurance companies
  • Compare the lowest rates
  • Fast and free for all driving records
  • Available in Green Bay
Read More
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Snapshot driving tool
  • Mobile app
  • Bundle & save
  • Available in Green Bay

See car insurance within your budget with the Name Your Price tool. Get a personalized rate based on your driving with Snapshot. 99% of drivers earn at least one of multiple discounts. Insures over 20 million drivers.

Read More
Liberty Mutual
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Accident forgiveness
  • 12-month rate guarantee
  • 24/7 claims online
  • Available in Green Bay

Customizes car insurance so you pay only for what you need. Has add-ons for new vehicle replacement, accident forgiveness and deductible savings. Over 15 types of discounts. Use the app to get ID cards, pay a bill or file a claim.

Read More
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Emergency towing
  • Mobile app to file claim or pay bill
  • Shopping discounts and rewards program
  • Discounts available with AAADrive mobile app

Provides auto insurance through regional clubs. May require membership in order to purchase a policy. Provides roadside assistance, discounts and deals, travel planning tools and financial services to over 57 million members.

Read More
The General
  • Driving record forgiveness
  • Low down payments
  • Military discounts
  • Available in Green Bay
Read More
Pagel & Associates Insurance Agency
  • Personal agents walk through your options
  • Independent agent not tied to any one company
  • Offers other types of insurance
  • Based in Green Bay
1497 6th St., Ste. E
Green Bay, WI 54304
(920) 544-0687
Read More
Total Insurance Services
  • M-Th: 8am - 5pm
  • F: 8am - 4pm
  • Closed Sat and Sun
  • totalinsurancegreenbay.com
2250 Fox Heights Ln.
Green Bay, WI 54324
(920) 494-7979
Avid Risk Solutions
  • M-F: 8am - 4:30pm
  • Closed Sat and Sun
  • avidrisk.com
1011 South Spring St.
Beaver Dam, WI 53916
(920) 885-5252
Valley Insurance Associates
  • M-F: 8am - 5pm
  • Closed Sat and Sun
  • vizance.com
3962 N. Richmond St.
Appleton, WI 54913
(920) 733-4944
Parish Insurance Agency
  • M-F: 8:30am - 4:30pm
  • Closed Sat and Sun
  • parishinsurance.net
2475 University Ave., Ste. H
Green Bay, WI 54308
(920) 468-9464
Tartan Insurance Agency
  • M-Th: 8am - 4:30pm
  • F: 8am - 3pm
  • Closed Sat and Sun
  • tartaninsurance.com
1540 Capitol Dr., Ste 106
Green Bay, WI 54303
(920) 494-7421
  • M-F: 9am - 5pm
  • Closed Sat and Sun
  • meemic.com/insurance-agency/wisconsin/green-bay/schoolhouse-agency
417 S. Monroe
Green Bay, WI 54301
(920) 489-2318

How to choose car insurance in Green Bay

Green Bay Skyline

The average Green Bay resident has nearly 20 minutes of commute time, and the public transit system has limited routes. That makes cars a necessity for most people in Green Bay. In addition to car payments, gas and maintenance, car insurance is an expense that comes with vehicle ownership.

In the state of Wisconsin, motorists are required to carry liability coverage in the amounts of $25,000 for injury or death of one person, $50,000 for injury or death of one more than person and $10,000 for property damage. State law also requires uninsured motorist coverage, which protects you if you get into an accident with an at-fault driver who doesn’t have liability insurance. Drivers operating a car without insurance can be fined up to $500 in Wisconsin.

Keep in mind that these are only minimum necessary coverages. Many drivers and car owners protect their assets by purchasing additional coverage. This can include:

  • Collision coverage, which pays for damage to your vehicle due to a collision with a vehicle or object
  • Comprehensive coverage, which pays for damage to your vehicle due to fire, vandalism, water, hail, glass breakage, wind, falling objects, civil commotion or hitting an animal
  • Medical payments coverage, which helps pay for medical or funeral expenses for you or your passengers after a car accident or if you or family members are hit by an automobile as a pedestrian or while riding in another vehicle

Deductibles, or the amount you owe before the insurance company makes payments, apply to both collision and comprehensive insurance for each incident.

How much does car insurance in Green Bay cost?

The cost of car insurance in Green Bay depends on a number of different factors, starting with policy specifics and the deductible. Other variables include the kind of car you drive, your driving record, how much you drive, where you live and park your car, your credit history and your age, sex and marital status.

ZIP code Average annual cost of car insurance
54301 (Green Bay, Allouez) $415
54302 (Green Bay, Bellevue) $413
54305 (Green Bay) $421
54307 (Allouez) $430
54303 (Green Bay, Howard) $421
54304 (Green Bay, Ashwaubenon) $418
54344 (De Pere) $421

Note: Based on a 40-year-old male with only liability coverage at $50K/$100K/$50K.

In Wisconsin the average annual premium is $1,040, making it the eighth cheapest state in the U.S., according to a 2018 report in the state’s largest newspaper. The average premium across the country is $1,427.

There are many ways to save when purchasing car insurance in Green Bay. When reviewing quotes and coverages, make sure to ask about possible discounts for paying in full up front, choosing a higher deductible, bundling with other policies, maintaining continuous coverage, increasing your credit score or driving an older car.

Car Insurance Reviews


Progressive, one of the largest auto insurers in the U.S., covers 18 million drivers across the country. Customers can save 5 percent or more on their auto insurance by bundling with home or renters insurance. Start by getting a fast, personalized, accurate quote online. Or you can visit a local agent in Green Bay. Many customers have used Progressive for years and appreciate the competitive prices and responsive service.


Liberty Mutual

Customers at Liberty Mutual benefit from discounts for purchasing multiple types of insurance, buying online and demonstrating good driving behavior. The company will contribute toward your deductible through its Liberty Mutual Deductible Fund. A 12-month rate guarantee, 24/7 customer service and a lifetime repair guarantee come standard. Numerous customers report saving money with Liberty Mutual.

Liberty Mutual


Customers purchasing auto insurance through AAA can take advantage of multiple discounts to save hundreds of dollars. Even if you are not a member, it’s easy to get a quote online. A number of different deductible levels and types of coverage are available, and claims professionals are reachable 24/7. Reviewers say Green Bay’s AAA office has helpful and knowledgeable staff.


The General

The General has been insuring automobiles and drivers of all types in the U.S. for over 50 years. Customers can get a fast quote and manage all aspects of their accounts online. The company’s website has a number of useful resources for first-time buyers of car insurance. Customers say the purchasing experience was straightforward and speak highly of the customer service.

The General

Pagel & Associates Insurance Agency

Pagel & Associates Insurance Agency is based in Green Bay. This independent agency offers plans from a number of different insurers and focuses on finding the policy right for individual customers. Green Bay residents can request a free, no-obligation quote and stop at the office to get any questions answered. Many reviewers give the agency five-star reviews and recommend it to others.

Pagel & Associates Insurance Agency